Processing Science at Scale to Traverse the ‘Valley of Death’ from Fundamental Science to Commercialization

By Bryan D. Vogt

Department of Polymer Engineering, University of Akron, Akron, OH

View Presentation

Additional materials available (4)

Licensed under General Performance Usage.

Published on

Abstract

Translation of innovation from fundamental research to commercial product is commonly hindered by the costs associated with scale-up and development of manufacturable processing routes. An integrated approach where concepts of scale-up, efficient processing, and cost are considered from the beginning of the research project will be described in the context of vignettes, described below, where manufacturable solutions to defined commercialization problems are being developed.

One challenge associated with emergent virtual reality (VR) platforms is motion sickness side-effects. The immersive experience of VR provides the sensation of motions through sight but fails to stimulate the vestibular network. This conflict in stimuli for the brain can lead to motion sickness and provides a challenge in mass adaptation of VR. Stimulation of the vestibular network requires electrical connections through the skin. Penetration of the stratum corneum by an external electrode is one solution, but would be subject to FDA scrutiny, increasing costs as well as creating risk of transference of disease from the sharing of VR devices. A recent dry electrode design based on a textured surface can compress the stratum corneum sufficiently to provide external electrical connection with the vestibular network through electrodes on the forehead, behind the ears, and back of the neck. However, user comfort is poor with this technology due to the rigid electrode, so when the user moves the skin is locally pinned by this electrode, causing discomfort. To overcome this challenge, a manufacturable roll-to-roll process is discussed. This process generates textured surfaces using magnetic fields that create rigid conductive channels protruding from the surface surrounded by an elastomer with mechanical properties similar to skin. This formulation is based on commercially available materials that have been developed independently: poly(dimethylsiloxane) as the elastic component and Ni@Ag particles (developed for EMF shielding paints) that are aligned by the magnetic field into columns to generate the more rigid and electrically conductive component. Production of the desired structures and conductivity can be readily controlled through process variables with the potential for on-the-fly modulation of the surface topology to enable extension to other applications.

Similarly, fundamental early-stage research can also benefit from consideration of scalability, processing and manufacturability. Shorter vignettes will be presented describing how these concepts can be applied generally to defined problems at various technical readiness levels (TRLs). At higher TRL, there remain challenges with obtaining excellent mechanical properties from 3D printing for plastic parts, which we overcome through a materials-centric approach that uses combinations of commodity plastics. Finally, we discuss how roll-to-roll processing is being used to fabricate low cost self-assembled materials for beyond Li ion battery technologies.

Sponsored by

Cite this work

Researchers should cite this work as follows:

  • Bryan D. Vogt (2018), "Processing Science at Scale to Traverse the ‘Valley of Death’ from Fundamental Science to Commercialization," https://nanohub.org/resources/28176.

    BibTex | EndNote

Time

Location

Room 1001, Birck Nanotehnology Center, Purdue. University, West Lafayette, IN

Processing Science at Scale to Traverse the ‘Valley of Death’ from Fundamental Science to Commercialization
  • Processing science at scale to traverse the 'valley of death' from fundamental science to commercialization 1. Processing science at scale to… 0
    00:00/00:00
  • Vogt Research Group 2. Vogt Research Group 30.43043043043043
    00:00/00:00
  • Scalable (nano)manufacturing 3. Scalable (nano)manufacturing 111.44477811144478
    00:00/00:00
  • Failure to launch… why 4. Failure to launch… why "bett… 154.18752085418754
    00:00/00:00
  • Integrating scalability into fundamental science/engineering 5. Integrating scalability into f… 206.13947280613948
    00:00/00:00
  • Developing scalable solutions 6. Developing scalable solutions 303.77043710377046
    00:00/00:00
  • 3 vignettes on scalability considerations 7. 3 vignettes on scalability con… 336.77010343677011
    00:00/00:00
  • Virtual reality 8. Virtual reality 370.27027027027026
    00:00/00:00
  • Visual and vestibular systems 9. Visual and vestibular systems 448.14814814814815
    00:00/00:00
  • Vestibular network 10. Vestibular network 476.87687687687691
    00:00/00:00
  • Stimulation of the vestibular network 11. Stimulation of the vestibular … 509.30930930930936
    00:00/00:00
  • Proof of concept for dry electrodes 12. Proof of concept for dry elect… 605.10510510510517
    00:00/00:00
  • Problems with design 13. Problems with design 661.1945278611945
    00:00/00:00
  • Ideal design? 14. Ideal design? 740.17350684017356
    00:00/00:00
  • Alternative disruptive manufacturing? 15. Alternative disruptive manufac… 799.265932599266
    00:00/00:00
  • Alignment of particles? 16. Alignment of particles? 828.86219552886223
    00:00/00:00
  • Considering manufacture in materials selection 17. Considering manufacture in mat… 864.16416416416416
    00:00/00:00
  • Magnetic field induced surface structures 18. Magnetic field induced surface… 931.69836503169836
    00:00/00:00
  • Conductivity through thickness 19. Conductivity through thickness 979.51284617951285
    00:00/00:00
  • Decreasing the Ag requirement 20. Decreasing the Ag requirement 1028.7954621287954
    00:00/00:00
  • Flexible electrodes from R2R processing 21. Flexible electrodes from R2R p… 1112.0453787120455
    00:00/00:00
  • Summary 22. Summary 1159.9933266599933
    00:00/00:00
  • 3 vignettes on scalability considerations 23. 3 vignettes on scalability con… 1226.6933600266934
    00:00/00:00
  • 3D printing of polymers 24. 3D printing of polymers 1258.6252919586254
    00:00/00:00
  • Challenges of 3D printing by FFF 25. Challenges of 3D printing by F… 1284.6513179846513
    00:00/00:00
  • Challenges of FFF 26. Challenges of FFF 1345.679012345679
    00:00/00:00
  • Hypothetical 27. Hypothetical "ideal" behavior 1391.9586252919587
    00:00/00:00
  • Structured multicomponent filament 28. Structured multicomponent fila… 1428.9956623289957
    00:00/00:00
  • Printing core-shell filament 29. Printing core-shell filament 1484.8181514848181
    00:00/00:00
  • Impact properties – Bane of 3D printing 30. Impact properties – Bane of … 1519.5195195195197
    00:00/00:00
  • Examination of crack tip 31. Examination of crack tip 1565.6322989656323
    00:00/00:00
  • Impact properties (IZOD) 32. Impact properties (IZOD) 1612.2122122122123
    00:00/00:00
  • Printability of the filaments 33. Printability of the filaments 1659.592926259593
    00:00/00:00
  • Inhibition of crack formation by core reinforcement 34. Inhibition of crack formation … 1734.2676009342677
    00:00/00:00
  • Summary 35. Summary 1769.4361027694363
    00:00/00:00
  • 3 vignettes on scalability considerations 36. 3 vignettes on scalability con… 1804.1374708041376
    00:00/00:00
  • Challenge: Competitive sustainable energy 37. Challenge: Competitive sustain… 1828.6286286286288
    00:00/00:00
  • Potential Li issue 38. Potential Li issue 1874.9749749749751
    00:00/00:00
  • Alternative battery platforms 39. Alternative battery platforms 1942.575909242576
    00:00/00:00
  • High temperature Na - S 40. High temperature Na - S 1977.1104437771105
    00:00/00:00
  • Room temperature Na-S battery 41. Room temperature Na-S battery 2029.2625959292627
    00:00/00:00
  • Porous conductors for Li-S 42. Porous conductors for Li-S 2110.0767434100767
    00:00/00:00
  • Scalable synthesis of carbon fibers 43. Scalable synthesis of carbon f… 2194.0940940940941
    00:00/00:00
  • Roll-to-roll processing 44. Roll-to-roll processing 2219.4861528194861
    00:00/00:00
  • R2R fabrication 45. R2R fabrication 2234.9683016349686
    00:00/00:00
  • Structure of materials 46. Structure of materials 2340.7741074407741
    00:00/00:00
  • Surface chemistry effects 47. Surface chemistry effects 2386.152819486153
    00:00/00:00
  • Scalable co-doping 48. Scalable co-doping 2448.5819152485819
    00:00/00:00
  • Codoping from XPS 49. Codoping from XPS 2497.997997997998
    00:00/00:00
  • Doping stops sulfur crystallization 50. Doping stops sulfur crystalliz… 2563.4634634634635
    00:00/00:00
  • Diffusion inhibition 51. Diffusion inhibition 2630.7974641307974
    00:00/00:00
  • Impact on Na-S battery performance 52. Impact on Na-S battery perform… 2669.4361027694363
    00:00/00:00
  • Summary 53. Summary 2735.8692025358691
    00:00/00:00
  • Acknowledgments 54. Acknowledgments 2767.2005338672006
    00:00/00:00